The Best San Diego Pie Shops and Purveyors
From flaky savory pastries filled with chicken and gravy to fruit pies packed with seasonal spices like cinnamon, cloves, and nutmeg (and, of course, topped with whipped cream or served a la mode), one
thing’s certain — one slice of pie is never enough. American classics like apple, pumpkin, and Key lime pie are standard offerings across most pie shops, but San Diegans need not stray away from less common options like Cuban pastelitos de carne to New Zealand-style pockets of golden crust stuffed with lamb and cheddar cheese. Find a list of the best pie offerings in San Diego below.
Village Kitchen and Pie ShoppeYelp" />
950 Tamarack Avenue, Carlsbad, CA 92008, USA
(760) 729-6414
This Carlsbad old-school American cafe has been around for decades, slinging homestyle pies since the 1990s. Open as early as 7 a.m., the restaurant offers a full menu — including breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert — that’s available all day long. Stop by for a morning slice of fruit-filled pie (flavors range from apple, peach, and strawberry-rhubarb crunch to blueberry and boysenberry) to pair with a steamy cup of coffee. Cream-filled pies like lemon, banana, and coconut are also on the menu, along with seasonal and special offerings such as pumpkin, Oreo Cookie, and sour cream versions. Pick up a whole pie in store or place an order 24 hours in advance online.
Julian Pie CompanyYelp" />
4131 Ashton Street, San Diego, CA 92110, USA
(619) 275-1234
Most San Diegans know that Julian is the premier destination for a warm slice of apple pie topped with vanilla ice cream. But pies from the longtime Julian Pie Company can still be secured without having to go too far — just head to a nearby grocery store instead. From several variations of apple fillings, including classic and Dutch, along with boysenberry, cherry, and rhubarb, sugar-free options are also available; pies from the well-known Southern California company are carried in stores all over the county, such as Vons, Mission Gorge Farmers Market, Baron’s, and Albertson’s. Visit the website to find the closest location that carries Julian Pie Company favorites.
Pop PieFacebook" />
4404 Park Boulevard, Suite A, San Diego, CA 92116, San Diego, CA 92116, USA
(619) 900-4743
This locally owned fast-casual pie shop specializes in handmade, artisanal pies with both sweet and savory fillings. A long list of signature flavors inspired by Australia, Europe, and Asia ranges from green hog or slow-braised pork shoulder and cheese to lemon curd and mixed berries. Seasonal favorites such as salted caramel apple, pumpkin cream cheese, and chocolate pecan, are also available by the slice or as a whole pie. Frozen pies, cookies, beverages, and sides like creamed corn and mashed potatoes are also offered daily.
San Diego Chicken Pie Shop
2633 El Cajon Boulevard, San Diego, CA 92104, USA
(619) 295-0156
A staple in San Diego, Chicken Pie Shop has been drawing in guests for years thanks to its “World Famous” classic chicken pot pie dinner stacked with whipped potatoes, vegetables, coleslaw, a roll, and dessert for less than $20 (a cup of soup can be added for a few more dollars). For breakfast, consider the Neighborhood Grind with chicken pot pie, two eggs bathed in gravy, hash browns, and either bacon or sausage. A visit to the chicken pie shop is incomplete without a slice of sweet pie — banana, lemon, chocolate and coconut make great options.
Beginners Diner
2223 El Cajon Boulevard, CA 92104
(619) 296-2101
Take a trip down memory lane at Beginner’s Diner, a 1940s-style diner nestled inside the Lafayette Hotel. Cozy up in a nostalgic booth or at the long counter that hovers over black-and-white checkered floors. Open 24 hours a day, the old-school diner’s selection of homemade pies features lemon meringue, cherry, apple, and chess pie. Grab a slice after cocktails at one of the hotel’s many bars or pair it with the diner’s boozy milkshakes available in flavors like strawberry, chocolate hazelnut, and banana coconut.
Great MapleFacebook" />
1451 Washington Street, San Diego, CA 92103, USA
(619) 255-2282
American classics are served with a slice of pie at Great Maple, a mid-century modern venue offering brunch, lunch, and dinner daily. The Hillcrest outpost is often visited for its Key lime pie — a treat with creamy, tart Key lime filling with a classic graham crust, whipped cream, and powdered sugar. Check in with the waitstaff for the monthly specials with rotating pie flavors like chocolate cream. Be sure to place pickup orders for whole pies at least 48 hours in advance.
Bread and Cie Bakery
350 University Ave, San Diego, CA, 92103, US
(619) 683-9322
The Hillcrest cafe and bakery offers everything from grilled panini to individual tarts and whole pies baked in house. The approachable environment makes for a great lunch spot and coworking space during the week. Tarts are a good way to try different flavors (almond pear, lemon, fruit, and pumpkin). For a more filling dessert option, try a slice of the many pies available daily: tiramisu, French apple, apple raspberry rhubarb, pecan, blackberry, and pumpkin cranberry. Call ahead to preorder pies, especially during the holidays.
4820 Newport Avenue, San Diego, CA 92107, USA
(619) 523-2020
Cuban pastries line the counter at this Ocean Beach shop but the savory offerings are equally as important. The meat pies or pastelitos de carne are the main highlight at Azucar — the hand-sized pies just under $4 come filled with a homemade picadillo (ground beef cooked down with white wine, tomato, olives, raisins, peppers, onions, and garlic) encased in an all-butter puff pastry. Grab a few flaky pies for dinner and finish with something sweet like a Key lime pie square with berries and coconut meringue. Don’t skip the coffee beverages on the way out — a Cuban espresso or cortadito would pair perfectly with the pastries offered daily.
Peace PiesCourtesy Photo" />
4230 Voltaire Street, San Diego, CA 92107, USA
(619) 223-2880
This award-winning spot for raw, vegan, and gluten-, peanut-, and soy-free food in Ocean Beach (which has a second location in Leucadia) has pie options on the menu that are worth trying, including their famed cosmic coconut cream with cashews, coconut, vanilla, almond, and dates, and Alive apple (apple, cinnamon, dates, and almonds), along with cheesecakes in flavors like white chocolate blackberry and lemon raspberry. (Check the display case for daily specials.) Custom cheesecakes and pies are ready for pickup within 48 hours of placing an order over the phone.
Dunedin New Zealand Eats
3501 30th Street, San Diego, CA 92104, USA
(619) 255-8566
Savory pies with a New Zealand twist are top sellers at Dunedin’s North Park venue. Under the NZ Favorites section on the menu, find meat pies packed with seasoned beef, lamb, and cheddar cheese or their version of chicken pot pie featuring hand-pulled chicken in a savory bread pudding. Ask for the meat pie and chips dish or try the vegetarian pie option with two curry pies and fries .
Extraordinary Desserts
2870 4th Avenue, San Diego, CA, 92103, US
+16192942132
Just as extravagant as they are decadent, the sweet creations at Extraordinary Desserts make every special occasion that much sweeter. Owner and executive pastry chef of more than 30 years Karen Krasne has elevated her pies by adding fresh flowers and high-quality ingredients, curating an ever-changing menu of whole pies and tartlets made with fruit, custard, cream, and a buttery crust. Go for an individual-sized petite coconut or banana cream pie or take home a seasonal offering like the Valrhona chocolate pecan with dark chocolate, whiskey, and butterscotch pecan filling. For pumpkin pie with an island twist, try the Aloha that has a roasted coconut pecan crust, dollops of marshmallow coconut milk whipped cream, roasted pecans, and edible gold leaf. Ask for a scoop of homemade ice cream to make any pie a la mode.